HPRgument Blog — June 12, 2010 6:37 pm

Does buying gold make you a bad person? (Markets Overview)

By Carrie Summer

There’s been a lot of volatility in the markets since April; investors and economists are nervous about an impending “double dip” that will send America and the world into another economic gloom.

In my opinion, President Obama should turn his attention towards the stability of the global economic system. Granted, the President seems to be responding to the fact that upcoming election(s) will be based on anger. But as The Economist has commented recently, anger without new ideas is impotent. This is especially true as economists are questioning the potential for continued recovery. What will happen if Europe’s debt crisis drags us into Great Recession #2? Whose ass can we kick then? Anger will quickly turn to fear, a fear that the President must be competent to address. The U.S. hasn’t really been involved in the Eurozone’s troubles so far, beyond asking Europe to spend more on stimulus. Maybe it’s time to for the President to take more of a public leadership role and calm the markets, rather than just sending out Bernanke to make vague comments.

In other news, CNBC reports that one group is happy about the recent downturn – short sellers.

Generally, investment makes one want things to go well. Investors hope that the economy improves, that consumers are not taxed too much and have money to spend, that companies succeed and make the things that consumers want to buy, that consumers are employed, etc.

But when you buy gold (which gains value when people trade in their stocks for its relative safety) or short stocks, you make your money when the market falls. As a short seller, you lose money when stock prices rise. If the stock’s price goes down, you earn money. When markets crash, you earn lots and lots of money. This creates a situation where you sit around praying for the sky to fall, for war and political turmoil, for consumers and be unemployed, for companies to go bankrupt and Greece to default on its debts. Same goes with gold speculation, basically. I know someone who’s invested in gold and pretty much hopes for a double dip. Now that’s moral hazard.

*Just to clarify – I’m not proposing to should ban shorts altogether (Note: Germany has banned only the “naked” speculative kind), because some investors buy these instruments (in addition to stocks) to hedge against a potential market drop that they don’t hope for.

Image Credit: Flickr (Peyri Herrera)

Related posts:

Obama Mad Libs
Biden and Gibbs Mad Libs
Social Studies Walkout: Video
Breaking Down The Super Committee
  • Gold Buyer

    In case you want an answer, buying gold makes you a smart person, interested in building wealth during a time when the administration is destroying the dollar. So, when I was investing in tech stocks prior to the start of Obama’s printing press, was I a good person? My god – write something worth reading.

  • Carrie Summer

    The title was a bit tongue in cheek, but you bring up a valid point, Gold Buyer. Most investors take “political risk” and economic developments as exogenous. Rather than thinking too much about the ethical implications of various positions, or God forbid, trying to shape government actions or societal discourse through blogging, they just react to perceived risks and opportunities. So perhaps yeah – not worth reading for the gold buyers.

  • Carrie Summer

    The dollar’s doing great, btw.

  • http://wethesheeplez.blogspot.com/ John Doe

    Carrie Summer
    2010-06-12
    22:09:40The dollar’s doing great, btw.

    The dollars doing great until it collapses…
    If a country could create great wealth by printing money created out of thin air…Zimbabwe would be the richest country in the world…

  • JY

    I think Ben Bernanke would take offense at the characterization that he’s being trotted out by anyone!

  • GMiki

    Buying gold makes you a person who has studied up. We didn’t create the situation–the derivitives, the debt, the market manipulations, the frauds, the lies…

  • http://kitco.com neville

    In todays market free for all such as Sub Prime,High Speed Trading,QE,Too Big to fail syndrome etc etc and overall world bankruptcy the author of this futile article tries to throw a moral curve ball at the owners and would be buyers of GOLD for taking their absolute “democratic right to insurance” …….What a sick joke

    For their ineptitude and gross mismanagement of the worlds economy ,finance ministers the world over were courting the first DIP and their continued failure to address those problems which caused the first dip have NOT gone away ….SO its a double scoop of the same coming up .

    Thats what they wanted …..thats what they will get.

    This article by Carrie Summer gives full credibility and justification to Mr Gerald Celente and others to criticise her and her colleagues from Harvard, Princeton and Yale to the hilt .The utterings of writers of such drivel court severe cricism for making incoherent statements on the subject for which very are few are able to comment.

    What about us buying diamonds from Israel??? just now she will tell us that those are blood diamonds in the wake of the flotilla incident. Who knows

  • JR Shepard

    Shill.

  • http://Kitco jfdanyko

    I am an investor in PM mining assets. I do my own research and project future earnings based on a conservative model for purchasing my target stocks. Resources are not just a hedge, they follow the same economic supply and demand models as bond & any other investing asset.

    Many Finacial Advisors advicate up to 10% of PM in an investors portfolio but guess what thier is only about 165,000 tons of gold above ground and not every investor can get 10%. Thier is just not enough gold in the world. The world only add about 75 m oz a year.

    GLD holds less than 1% of the world above ground gold. The US Reserves are only holds about 5% of the above ground reserves.

    I have no problem with the average American owning gold as part of their assets, plus Gold has no debt against it!

    Joe Danyko M.S.B.A. (Quality & Project Management)

  • Tony Hancock

    What a moronic, immoral and offensive article. Moral hazard is failing to control a budget and consequently debasing a currency to oblivion. Buying gold is a way to protect oneself against this hazard. As Alan Greenspan said:

    “Deficit spending is simply a scheme for the confiscation of wealth. Gold stands in the way of this insidious process. It stands as a protector of property rights.”

  • Alan Sugar

    I have no idea who Carrie Summer is, but she comes across as a sanctimonious cretin with zero understanding of free markets. In days gone by, idiots like this would have done society a service by disappearing off to Asia with the Peace Corps to kindly get themselves shot; but sadly nowadays we have to put up with their nonsense online.

    The real crime is whatever numbnut saw fit to promote her into doing anything more taxing than basketweaving or tie-dye. But well done Carrie, you’ve spelled the word exogenous correctly. Buy yourself a fair trade coffee to celebrate and best of luck in your future career as a true hero blogging illiterate quasi-marxist crap.

  • kenny the king

    this is typical demoncrat strategy. try to pike holes in anything that is counter-adminastrative. if you really think things are going great, then don’t buy any. i’ll continue trading phony paper for real money and you can continue thinking barry o’bama is doing a great job. we will see how ir works out.
    by the way, dollar great guy. the dollar is only doing well visa via other paper currency. notably the euro. look at euro vs.dollar.

  • Pingback: Weighing In: The Big Short « The Harvard Political Review

custom writing